Last week Amazon released five new tablet devices, two eReaders and three tablets. I’m honestly pretty mired in the Amazon infrastructure, owning a Kindle Touch eReader (4th Generation), a first generation Kindle Fire and my wife’s Kindle Fire HD, so I was curious if these devices had anything to offer (particularly if my current generation of devices ever stops working). Here’s my rundown of each:
Kindle (7th Generation) now with Touch ($79 with special offers):
This is the first eReader Amazon’s put out in a while that I actually think is as good of a device as my current Kindle. My 4th Generation Touch has a 4GB capacity, has a speaker out for MP3 playback, can support text-to-speech as well as simple games and a web-browser, and cost me about $100 at the time I bought it.
As with all eReader’s these days, the new Kindle has none of the extras the old Touch did (except maybe the browser and active content), but at least it finally has a 4GB capacity again (I was getting kind of annoyed at looking at $119 devices with only 2GB capacity). The product specs say its a little faster and a little lighter, but basically this is the same dependable Kindle device you’ve come to know and love. It’s nice that the low-end Kindle now has touch as this is an essential eReader capability. 167 ppi might sound low when compared to the 212 and 300 of their other reader devices, but trust me, its fine.
My old Nook Simple Touch was a better device with an expansion slot for more books (up to 8 times the capacity) and side buttons as well as touch, but unfortunately nobody bought them and now Nook only sells the GlowLight and the Samsung Tablet *sigh*.
This doesn’t have the back-lighting of the Paperwhite, but personally I’ve never understood that feature. Why build a night-light into the device for which you’re paying at least $20-40 extra, when a stand-alone clip on night-light or heaven forbid, lamps, are so much cheaper?
I’ll probably end up replacing my old Touch with this device eventually, though I will miss the extras. But only when my old device dies.
Fire HD6 ($99 with special offers):
I’ll admit, this one is tempting. I’m a little bummed about the 8GB capacity, but for an extra $20 you can double that. And it comes in colors, though admittedly the only other one I’d consider is blue. I actually am fine with the old T-Model Ford colors (you get your choice of color, black).
I use my current 7″ (also 8GB) Fire tablet mostly to read comic books. And here’s where we hit a snag. Comic books are already a bit of a stretch a 7″, but are mostly readable with a little optimizing. But I have a feeling 6″ will feel too cramped. Now there are things like guided view (where you see each comic panel one at a time), but I’ve always felt this took away from the experience, and a lot of the comics I own are in PDF format from things like Humble Bundle (so no guided view).
For gaming on the other hand this should be a great device, with a quad core processor this can handle the heavy lifting on graphics intensive 6″ (mobile oriented) games. And that’ll make steaming to the device more pleasurable. However, I suspect this tablet will also run into stiff competition against phablets (phone tablets) and larger smart phones. 6″ doesn’t feel big enough to justify the separate device (even though it’s fine for the eReader, but that’s only text). It has front and rear cameras like most phones, but again people will probably be wondering why it can’t make calls.
Kindle Voyage ($199 with special offers):
This is Amazon’s foray into being more like Apple (i.e. producing a device for book snobs). It’s the same size as the regular Kindle (actually a tidge smaller) with more pixels (300 ppi vs 167 ppi), has a built in light with an adaptive light sensor, touch screen and “page press” a new technology that lets you turn pages without lifting a finger.
The Voyage by its own admission is trying its best to be an actual physical book book, and not an eReader. Pushing buttons and swiping fingers are considered unnatural reading experiences. I’m not exactly sure how page press works (would need an actual device to play with as their video doesn’t show much), but it basically seems like a combination of slightly moving your thumb and applying light pressure to turn pages.
As an engineer I doubt this was implemented perfectly the first time for all users. This feature will probably result in more accidental page turns than touch ever did. You know the best device that eliminated swipes? The Nook simple Touch with buttons on each side and a contoured back that fit naturally in your hand so you could just lightly press up and down to turn the page. *sigh* Last rant I promise.
You can get 3G with this device as well, but that’s really only necessary if you must be able to buy a book literally anywhere. Most of us avid readers are fine with loading the device on our free home WiFi and taking it out into the world.
This device seems expensive and tries to solve problems it will never be able to solve. If you’re really that much of a bibliophile, spend that $199 on real books. (Also it’s kind of a silly name).
Fire HD Kids Edition ($149 for 6″, $189 for 7″):
Basically this is a re-packaging of their new Fire HD6 and the HD7 with a hard shell case. It comes with a year free of Amazon FreeTime, which allows kids to play all sorts of apps and things, and Amazon will replace it no questions asked in the first 2 years if the kid drops it and breaks it.
$50 for a hardshell case and some apps feels expensive, considering that replacing the device outright would cost $99. But my basic feeling is this: you shouldn’t be buying an expensive tablet for your kid if they can’t be responsible enough to take care of it. Tablets and other devices of its ilk are being introduced to children too early. I know that there’s a lot of neat ways to entertain and maybe even learn on these devices, but I’d resist buying one until they were at least in 5th – 6th grade. That commercial that Amazon is airing for the Amazon Phone is disturbing (if you haven’t seen it it features 9-ish year old kids talking about watching Skyfall and The Hunger Games and also spending all day on their phones).
If you want to use a tablet with younger kids, buy it for yourself, and supervise its usage. (Okay I guess that technically was a rant too).
Fire HDX 8.9 ($379 with special offers – 16GB):
I can’t believe I’m paying nearly $400 for a device and I’m still getting ads. Look, honestly at this point buy an iPad. Or even better, any one of a dozen android tablets (ASUS brand especially) with the same capacity, size and hardware (and probably a lot cheaper). ‘Nuff said.
One other thing: Amazon introduced a payment plan for these devices (sounds like just one eReader and one tablet for each user). You pay 20% up front, and then the rest in installments for 4 months. Sneaky way to get people to buy technology they don’t really need, or considerate offering that lets you spread the pain? You decide.
2 responses to “Trube on Tech: Amazon’s new crop of tablets”
I’ve been considering upgrading my old faithful kindle. Gives me something to think about.
Nothing wrong with keeping old faithful tech either, as long as it suits your needs. I’m always tempted by the new, but I’m often just as happy (if not happier) with the old. Hope you enjoy whatever you decide.